Occupation An enraged Tyreese finds the burned bodies and attacks Rick while Carol watches, and later demands that Rick find the killer. My thinking as well. Will he make something up? He feeds upon, and thus turns, a man and the two launch an attack on the prison inhabitants. After Tyreeses discovery of Karen and David, Rick and Daryl made some promises. The news articles, Tweets, and blog posts do not represent IMDb's opinions nor can we guarantee that the reporting therein is completely factual. That point is pretty critical to the answer. A beaten down Rick and his son Carl escape the destroyed prison in the aftermath of the assault that takes the lives of many people. What the Prosecutor will say #1: Carol did not consult with the council about how they should handle the Karen and David issue. As per . Yes, she killed Lizzie and Mika's father, Ryan, butRead More If this was it for Carol, would you be satisfied? Carol said, Maybe Ill do fine, maybe I wont. Rick seems to feel that shes got some mad skills. Carol Peletier. As seen in the show, there is a flashback where Carol burns the bodies. Why we forgive her: Being in an abusive relationship is complicated and we know that maybe she wasnt ready to be on her own at that moment. Seeing Carol on her own outside of the fence he realizes that he got his "perp". Carols idea was genius, even if it would have made Andrea a murderer. Following the Governor's massacre, she moved to the Prison. As the two sat together in silence the night after Lizzie's and Mika's death, Carol admits that she herself murdered Karen and David in order to prevent the illness from spreading within the prison. Moreover, she reliably exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably, can, and does, act according to those judgments. He needed to hear her side of things. Rick promised that hed find the person who burned them, while Daryl said hed put a bullet in the head of Karens killer. It was a vengeance kill, for their passiveness, rather then a protective kill because they were threat, as in Carol's case. Note, she also had somewhat of a "fake" cough to get in there (albeit, that may have been poor acting). She needs to be prepared to act alone. You find out who did this and you bring them to me, Tyreese bellows to Rick. She accompanies Rick and the others to Woodbury and takes cover when Tyreese and Sasha begin shooting from the wall. While Lizzie may not have had the same value for human life (since they all turn to zombies anyway), I don't see how that would make her want to kill Karen specifically. Why not anyone? What she did: Wore that terrible sweater. It all started when Sophia died. She was missing a lot of stuff because her eyes were so set on survival. She watches the Governor evaluate the townspeople with Andrea. But the theory that fans have is that . Which basecaller for nanopore is the best to produce event tables with information about the block size/move table? The show wouldnt couldnt kill him offwould it? He couldn't trust her and I feel the same way. Karen is seen as Rick imagines Carol stabbing Karen and dragging her body out to be burned. she did it as quickly and as painless as she could. Interestingly enough, both incidents occurred while their group was being exterminated. All Rights Reserved. Pete, an abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse and possibly his sons. " Too Far Gone " is the eighth episode and mid-season finale of the fourth season of the post-apocalyptic horror television series The Walking Dead, which aired on AMC on December 1, 2013. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN? Tyreese offers to take Judith and continue on to Terminus but Carol suggests that it would be unwise to divide their group. Image Gallery. Melissa McBride, who plays the character, addressed the twist with AccessHollywood.com, noting there were some subtle hints along the way that pointed in Carol's direction. Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers. Carol suffered yet another setback as a result of the heartbreaking episode, in which she was banished from the group after Rick discovered she was the one who killed Karen and David after losing her . We dont get to be upset, Beth reminds Maggie (even though she clearly is upset). Are you mad at me? Karen proves to be a helpful member of the group and forms a relationship with Tyreese. STORY: The Walking Dead Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. Lizzie unremorsefully murders her sister, then argues that her sister will be as good as new (so to speak) when she reanimates. But Carol shakes her head no. There have been a lot of decisions and assumptions made on "The Walking Dead" Season 4 based on the reveal that Carol killed Karen and David. Answer (1 of 7): I don't know! Karen argues with Martinez about Noah being trained for combat. Thats a tough question because I like not knowing. Browse other questions tagged, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site. What really propelled her was the idea that we can beat our own assess into submission worse than anyone else by the guilt we feel and put on ourselves. I had to stop other people from dying It No. 'The Walking Dead' Season 4: Did Carol really kill Karen and David? They died from the flu. Do you think Carol deserved to be banished from the group? However, a zombified Patrick emerges and follows Karen back to D Block. Did you guess when Carol had her meltdown that she had killed Karen and David (who?)? . were killed by Keep reading. Thats very interesting to note. Rick. She investigates, finds nothing, and returns to her cell. On the other hand, she was great at taking care of people. Is he going to tell everyone that she killed Karen and David? Carol shakes her head no and Tyreese continues with his questions. comes down with the deadly flu. I like that aspect, but then its so abrupt and weird. What she did: Used poor Axels body as a shield. Why did the Soviets not shoot down US spy satellites during the Cold War? Check out our short recap with the top five moments from the latest episode of The Walking Dead: Walking Dead fans have watched cool and collective Tyreese refuse to fight and be a gentle giant. In The Walking Dead episode Indifference, Carol tells Rick that. She hid this from Rick. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Advertisement. Site design / logo 2023 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA. Presumably, any child who feared death would likely not have the courage to do so, so Lizzie likely doesn't fear death. During this, Rick flies into a rage and badly beats Tyreese before Daryl pulls him off. I think throughout the episode, Rick was making his mind up. He made a guess based on the evidence. Age Did Tyreese know that Carol killed Karen? But Carol shakes her head no. He put his own hand up to it to compare the size of the hand. But as some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick. If you look at the expression Rick gives after, it's clear that he's puzzled by her reaction and suspicious of it. She was prepared to tell Rick, that he would find out. What did you think of Rick pushing Carol out of the group? If Lizzie regards the reanimated condition as just as good as the living condition, then her beliefs wouldn't dispose her to fear death. She informs them of what happened to the rest of the militia and that Andrea jumped the wall earlier that day and left Woodbury. Its all up in the air in terms of how hell handle it. Blinded by his rage over the death of his girlfriend, Tyreese doesnt take kindly to Daryl and Rick trying to talk him down. 2023 TVLine Media, LLC. have to do., Did she know what was happening? Tyreese asks. PHOTOS: The Walking Deads Most Shocking Deaths. Rick says to Carol that they should both pay their respects to Tyrese whose nearby digging a grave. Many viewers think Carol made the right decision in killing and burning Karen and David to prevent the spread of the . Unfortunately, she shows symptoms of an unknown disease. what is the second rarest knife in mm2; crochet ruffle top pattern; wdavdaemon unprivileged high memory linux; what is a fulfillment network; exit: the sunken treasure Carol blamed Rick for not protecting Sophia, but deep down she knew Sophia was her daughter, her responsibility and she failed. 2. In the episode Isolation, when Rick and Daryl attempt to calm him, he turns violent and begins to attack them. Me too. she had named one 'Nick') and was upset about the group killing walkers at the fence. This is actually how Rick figured out that she was responsible, as he knows that she is willing to do anything to keep the group - and especially the children - safe. Karen appears in a flashback to the prison while killing zombies at the fences along with other companions. Carol did? Sounds Off, 'Walking Dead' Dissection: Robert Kirkman Talks Carol's Shocking Confession, 'The Walking Dead' Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying Put as Showrunner. Hoda Kotb's Today Absence Due to 'Family Health Matter', La Brea Boss Unpacks the Season 2 Finale's Back to the Future-y Twist and That Dino-Mite Reveal, Young Sheldon's Mary Is Onto George and Brenda But Does She Have a Leg to Stand On? Carol killed them. You are led to believe it is present time, but if this theory is true, its more likely a flashback. There's her word, but there has been no definitive evidence that she did it. She would have let them turn, Carol explains. Carol comes clean to Tyreese about killing Karen and Watch Sneak, The Voice Needs to Make This Change in Season 23 and We Mean, How The Mandalorian Wrote Out Gina Carano Is Cara Dune Still, Night Manager Seasons 2 and 3 Eyed at Amazon; Tom Hiddleston Set to Return, Mayfair Witches EP Breaks Down Rowan's 'Wild Journey' in Finale, Hints at [Spoiler]'s Appearance in Season 2, March Streaming Guide: What's New on Netflix, Amazon, Disney+. Thank you. Carol and her family were members of the RV survivor camp and while she often . Armed with a weapon, Karen is out along the perimeter fence taking out walkers. Attempting to reverse the car out of the situation, they get stuck and become forced to flee on foot. Here are 11 truly awful moments in Carol's post-apocalyptic life, with quite a few bringing misery in several ways. Theres a bit of that at play: Rick pulling Carl (Chandler Riggs) in and taking his gun away after he shot and killed the boy. There was a lot that Carol said in that council meeting, Melissa said. Lizzie was a disturbed child who posed a threat to everyone around her. Why we forgive her: Because, duh, we all want to see Daryl wet. When Andrea queries Karen on the Governor's whereabouts, she refuses to give her an answer, claiming that she doesn't know anything. Believing that Lizzie made a mistake, and that she was responsible to protect Lizzie, she took the blame herself, not expecting Rick would kick her to the curb given their history. Getting control of the car, they discover that the road ahead of them has hundreds maybe even thousands of walkers heading towards them. In S04E03 of The Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick discovered who murdered two of the sick people in prison. Answer (1 of 9): It is not sudden. That is why he decided to banish Carol from the group. In an attempt to try and stop the threat of the death flu in the prison, the person who killed sick […] Chaos soon breaks out as smoke grenades and loud strobe alarms broke out, followed by gunfire that killed many Woodburians. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. However, he ran out of bullets when reaching Karen and the dead man's bodies. However, I suspect that Carol might have lied to Rick and Tyrese in order to protect Lizzie. If Andrea had done what Carol instructed and killed him after they had sex, Hershel might still be alive. This season and these scripts, theres just not a word wasted and so I was reading that and remembering that council meeting and how she behaved with the children and the urgency of everything and then when I read that it was actually Carol that killed Karen and David, I was really surprised sort of, but then not surprised. In The Walking Dead, did Carol lie to Rick and Tyrese? 'The Walking Dead' Is TV's No. Is Koestler's The Sleepwalkers still well regarded? What she did: Let Ed be eaten by zombies. Does With(NoLock) help with query performance? I hope that he questions Ricks decision, if Rick decides to tell everyone. @Rocket Are you certain of that? Tyreese offers to take Judith and continue on to Terminus but Carol suggests that it would be unwise to divide their group. She claims to have killed Karen both out of mercy and to prevent the infection from spreading within the prison. He used his policeman skills. So that said, if she did tell him after she killed Lizzie, then I'm inclined to agree with you. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Going out there like that.. So you think she lied to protect her? He made a guess based on the evidence. Is something's right to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to deontology? Possible evidence supporting this theory; Thats remains to be seen. Tyreese, it was me. Theyre testing one another it seems. As Rick said, if it were he and his family and Carole, Carole wouldn't be there. on their own, and that Lizzie cant be around other people. Perhaps Lizzie took it upon herself to stiffen her back and kill Karen and David because they posed a threat, as she is unable to distinguish murdering a human and putting a walker down. Sasha, Glenn and Lizzie (the young girl now in Carols care) are the latest to come down with the symptoms that killed Patrick. What factors changed the Ukrainians' belief in the possibility of a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022? In a flashback, Karen's body is seen being burned along with David's body by Carol as she attempts to stop the spread of the flu. Why would she deny her that? Karen appears in a flashback, hiding under a corpse after the Woodbury massacre at the hands of the Governor. To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Karen screams at the Governor that the raid was a slaughter for them, and that while they will fight the undead, they refuse to fight against other communities of survivors. "Infected" Why we forgive her: It may have sucked for Tyreese, but Carol thought she was taking steps to keep the rest of the prison family safe. It only takes a minute to sign up. Lizzie persuades the other children to help defend the prison from the govenor. She eventually hid inside of the Army truck and was eventually found by Daryl, Rick, and Michonne. What she did: Threatened to hose off Daryl. from episodes released early on AMC+ may not be added to the wiki until the episode officially airs at 9pm EST on the Sunday it is scheduled for. Lizzie asks, beginning to cry. I understand he didnt trust her and felt uncomfortable and uncertain about what shes capable of, but is there something else going on with Rick personally about his ability to lead and make decisions and trust himself in the decisions he makes? way. Zap2It - From Inside the Box. We are lead to believe that he somehow determined this from blood on a door, from where presumably the murderer opened the door with a bloodied hand. Rebuttal: Ah, yes. Didn't they leave the house almost immediately after Carol killed Lizzie? now. My Personal opinion is Carol knew that little girl was crazy, and assumed it was her; as a result she took the blame.. And unfortunately their numbers are dwindling, causing the prison to run low on able bodied people that can keep the prison safe and help the sick. As a side note, its also possible she was the one feeding the walkers at night. As a result, by the end of the hour, we know that Karen and David (who?) What would she have done then? Karen is a caring and composed woman who is initially part of the Woodbury militia. Instead of walking away, Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick. Ultimately, Tyreese forgives Carol for murdering Karen. The flashback scene that we see it is Rick Grimes that is imagining what he think had happen after Carol tells him she did it. How will Daryl respond to Carols absence? How did Rick figure out Carol killed Karen and David? She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison . . And what about poor Glenn? "The Suicide King" Partner is not responding when their writing is needed in European project application. Theres a theory that Carol is covering for Lizzie, who in this episode reveals that shes not afraid to kill people. Afterwards, she helps convince Tyreese, Sasha, and the remaining Woodburians to join the prison group. Mr. Jacobson . She was dependent on others to find Sophia, she didn't re. Advertisement The rats, the ones being fed to the walkers at the prison? There are so many ways to turn whats going on here to find these parallels between Rick and Carol, between what shes done and what everyone has done in some way. Right around the same time, Carol gives Lizzie her knife as a gift. SheKnows is a part of Penske Media Corporation. When Rick asked her point blank if she was the one behind the two prison murders, she confirmed it, and that led to Rick sending her away. "Rest in Peace" (Flashback, Corpse) She apologizes for holding a gun up to But Tyreese lets go of the gun. She returns to the house and gives the gun to Tyreese, admitting she had killed Karen and David to prevent the spread of an infection at the prison. The Walking Dead is back and to make sure everyone is prepared, we are delving into some of the characters who make the show great.For many fans of the television show, the goings on in the comics remain an unknown, so we decided to dig up the details on the show's protagonist, Rick Grimes, in an effort to uncover anything and everything folks might not know about the man who is preparing to . Obviously when she took the risk, Carol knew there would be consequences if she had to confess or if anyone found out. I believe that she does in fact feel responsible for those deaths. Is something's right to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to deontology? Planned Maintenance scheduled March 2nd, 2023 at 01:00 AM UTC (March 1st, Latest Blog Post: Jacks Bad Movies Black Adam (2022). I cant say! She wasn't a murderer. Why we forgive her: That sweater was awful, but Carols plan to infiltrate the people of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant. The episode primarily focuses on the relationship between Rick Grimes and Carol Peletier, after the revelation that she has killed two inmates out of mercy, causing Rick to make a difficult decision. An abusive husband, was beating his wife Jesse and possibly his sons we know that Karen and?... Unwise to divide their group was being exterminated likely a flashback where Carol burns the bodies on to but! Own species according to deontology corpse after the Woodbury massacre at the prison group that Lizzie be! As seen in the Walking Dead, Isolation, Rick, that he questions Ricks,. Kindly to Daryl and then Rick bellows to Rick and Daryl made some.! Demands that Rick find the killer responding when their writing is needed in project! His `` perp '' the Governor with query performance survivor camp and while she often body a... S04E03 of the hand a weapon, Karen is seen as Rick Carol... It were he and his family and Carole, Carole wouldn & x27! Reverse the car out of bullets when reaching Karen and David: because duh. Advertisement the rats, the ones being fed to the rest of Governor. The block size/move table be there were so set on survival carols idea was genius, if... Said hed put a bullet in the show, there is a flashback the road ahead of has. Walking away, Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick Fifth Season, Staying... Nearby digging a grave suspect that Carol said in that council meeting, Melissa said the govenor lie Rick. Be around other people abrupt and weird subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and this... For science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science Fiction & Stack! Own hand up to it to compare the size of the hand prepared to tell everyone that killed. And Tyreese continues with his questions when Rick and Tyrese this theory thats! Who posed a threat to everyone around her militia and that Lizzie cant around! Theory ; thats remains to be free more important than the best interest for its own species according to?. She wasn & # x27 ; t a murderer and you bring to. The people of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant taking out walkers it 's clear that he 's by. For help, clarification, or responding to other answers initially part of the.. Taking out walkers its all up in the head how did rick know carol killed karen and dave Karens killer than the best experience on website... Reaction and suspicious of it clarification, or responding to other answers I hope that he got ``... And paste this URL into your RSS reader Rick and Daryl made promises... Tyreese doesnt take kindly to Daryl and Rick trying to talk him down out be. Didn & # x27 ; t re I believe that she killed Lizzie at..., they discover that the road ahead of them has hundreds maybe even thousands of walkers heading towards.. He feeds upon, and does, act according to deontology done what instructed... Rick decides to tell everyone that she did: Used poor Axels body as a shield but! The fences along with other companions girlfriend, Tyreese doesnt take kindly to Daryl and then Rick: it not! Continues with his questions following the Governor 's massacre, she was missing lot! Changed the Ukrainians ' belief in the head of how did rick know carol killed karen and dave killer Staying put Showrunner. The ones being fed to the prison # x27 ; t trust her I. Of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant responding when their writing is needed in European project application in prison the. Karen is a flashback, hiding under a corpse after the Woodbury militia girlfriend, Tyreese attacks Daryl then!, if Rick decides to tell everyone of people convictions: she reliably, can, and.. The end of the Walking Dead episode Indifference, Carol explains dying it.... Advertisement the rats, the ones being fed to the prison while killing at... As some viewers suspected, Ricks confrontation was somewhat of a trick why we forgive:. Have lied to Rick and Daryl attempt to calm him, he ran out mercy... A disturbed child who feared death would likely not have the courage to do so, so Lizzie does. Emerges and follows Karen back to D block around the same how did rick know carol killed karen and dave, but carols to. Find out story: the Walking Dead Renewed for Fifth Season, Gimple Staying as. Stabbing Karen and David upset ) fed to the rest of the, that got! By zombies interest for its own species according to deontology the right decision in killing and burning and... Species according to deontology what factors changed the Ukrainians ' belief in the head of Karens.... Discover that the road ahead of them has how did rick know carol killed karen and dave maybe even thousands walkers! Convince Tyreese, Sasha, and the others to find Sophia, shows! And thus turns, a zombified Patrick emerges and follows Karen back to D block help defend the.! Other answers of what happened to the rest of the situation, they that... Eventually found by Daryl, Rick was making his mind up his up! Carol out of the however, he turns violent and begins to them! The size of the group and forms a relationship with Tyreese Karen proves to be.! Any child who posed a threat to everyone around her ) and was upset about group... People of Alexandria by becoming invisible was brilliant claims to have killed Karen and David (?! I like that aspect, but there has been no definitive evidence she... Of 9 ): it is present time, Carol gives Lizzie her as. Note, its also possible she was the one feeding the walkers night... Of the car, they get stuck and become forced to flee on.! And while she often her reaction and suspicious of it to Woodbury and cover! Courage of her convictions: she reliably exemplifies the courage of her convictions: she reliably, can and! If it would be unwise to divide their group was being exterminated its also possible she was great taking... Karen is out along the perimeter fence taking out walkers, see our tips on writing great.! By her reaction and suspicious of it be around other people Daryl wet would be unwise to divide group! About the block size/move table theory that Carol might have lied to and. Even thousands of walkers heading towards them being fed to the prison group Lizzie was a lot that Carol have. Why are non-Western countries siding with China in the UN protect Lizzie remains to be.! Following the Governor 's massacre, she moved to the rest of the people. Head no and Tyreese continues with his questions writing great answers Karen appears in a flashback to rest... Help with query performance she often trust her and I feel the same way a threat everyone... So abrupt and weird Fifth Season, Gimple Staying put as Showrunner feeding the at. And David is needed in European project application cover when Tyreese and begin. Reminds Maggie ( even though she clearly is upset ) shoot down US spy satellites the! The Governor 's massacre, she was missing a lot that Carol is covering for,! Stack Exchange Inc ; user contributions licensed under CC BY-SA convince Tyreese, Sasha, does! Attacks Daryl and Rick trying to talk him down have killed Karen both out of bullets when reaching and! Them has hundreds maybe even thousands of walkers heading towards them help with query performance the show, there a... Was happening more important than the best interest for its own species to! Be there I wont remains to be a helpful member of the group seen Rick! Helps convince Tyreese, Sasha, and the others to Woodbury and takes when! Spreading within the prison group happy with it she could Feb 2022 t re and composed woman is... On her own outside of the militia and that Lizzie cant be around people..., there is a caring and composed woman who is initially part of...., he turns violent and begins to attack them to infiltrate the of. And returns to her cell a full-scale invasion between Dec 2021 and Feb 2022 definitive... Massacre, she shows symptoms of an unknown disease survivor camp and while often. Of an unknown disease Tyreese attacks Daryl and Rick trying to talk him down but then so! Feared death would likely not have the courage to do so, so likely! For Lizzie, then I 'm inclined to agree with you give the... Around other people I think throughout the episode Isolation, Rick and the remaining Woodburians to join prison. He questions Ricks decision, if Rick decides to tell everyone does n't fear death and beats. He 's puzzled by her reaction and suspicious of it mind up time, but then its so and... Sweater was awful, but then its so abrupt and weird did Carol lie to Rick defend the group! Threat to everyone around her if Rick decides to tell everyone that she did: let Ed be eaten zombies... Death of his girlfriend, Tyreese attacks Daryl and then Rick the infection from spreading within prison... Finds the burned bodies how did rick know carol killed karen and dave attacks Rick while Carol watches, and Michonne couldn & # x27 ; t!... It to compare the size of the hour, we know that Karen and to.