In 1995, John Kalhauser killed his estranged wife. She most likely received the scratches as she was running through razor-sharp brush. Kalhauser was given twenty years in Arizona in 1999, no chance of an early release, to be served concurrently with his time in Massachusetts leaving him with a release date of 2025. We decide that the trial judge was incorrect in ruling that the sentence imposed on the prior conviction could be read along with the conviction for impeachment purposes, but that the error did not result in a substantial risk of a miscarriage of justice. In that same area, they also found a shirt and a jacket. Brenda's killer has not been brought to justice Billion Photos/Shutterstock He served only one before being released. He asserted he arrived home in Tyngsborough at around 2:30 A.M. and worked on his motorcycle through the night. Kalhauser lived in Tyngsboro at the time. Detected Status "Little Miss Nobody" (Sharon Lee Gallegos). When a party uses a prior conviction to impeach a witness, that party is limited to establishing the identity of the witness as the person named in the record.1 If the witness answers in the negative or equivocates on the answer then the questioner can use the facts contained in the record of conviction to establish the identity of the witness as the person named in the record of conviction.2 Those facts, however, do not include the details of the conviction, e.g., the victim's name or circumstances surrounding the event. Give Light and the People Will Find Their Own Way, INTERACTIVE RADAR: Tracking winter storm in Arizona. Male He thought that one day hed find her, that one day their children would play together. Arizona authorities said Brenda Gerow had been living with John Kalhauser at the time. When the police investigated, Donald Stecchi was discovered to be John Joseph Kalhauser, wanted on an outstanding warrant pertaining to his indictment in Massachusetts for attempted murder. Someone knows more about Gerows disappearance than the police or her brother. See Connecticut v. McClain, 23 Conn.App. Gallegos had reportedly been abducted from the alley behind her home in Alamogordo, New Mexico, on July 21, 1960, when she was 4 years old. Meantime, Kalhauser has only been named a "person of interest" as the investigation continues. Brendas last phone call was from Arizona. She ended up in Arizona with John Kalhauser. Kalhauser was arrested and released on bail. Bill felt like hed been abandoned by the sister he loved so much. Released on bail, the defendant fled to Arizona but was rearrested more than fifteen years later and brought to trial on the assault charges and several others in November, 1996. Those reports say the people in the vehicle offered to buy Gallegos candy and clothes if she got in the car, and when she refused, they dragged her inside and took off. That search reinforced their suspicions that the defendant was the shooter. The photo was recently found in possession of John Kalhauser, a convicted murderer, who refused to identify the woman pictured, according to police. 2 Player of the Year, Lowell boys basketball team tops Malden in Division 1 prelim, High school roundup: Vinny D'Urso, Lowell Catholic blank Haverhill, 1-0, MVC boys basketball: Tewksbury's Ryan Cuvier named Div. To see the dramatic recreation of the case, and how it was finally solved, tune into Who Killed Jane Doe? Her murderer, be it Kalhauser or someone else, needs to be found and punished. Neither did Gerow know that Kalhauser was already a convicted murderer. Ultimately, the judge acquiesced to defense counsel's request, ruling that if the defendant testified, the prosecutor could impeach him with his prior conviction for a felony.. Investigators in Arizona eventually realized the reconstructed facial image appeared to match the woman in the photograph that had been in Kalhausers possession. 258, 145 L.Ed.2d 216 (1999); State v. Washington, 383 S.W.2d 518, 523 (Mo.1964); State v. Finch, 293 N.C. 132, 141, 235 S.E.2d 819 (1977); State v. Sinclair, 57 N.J. 56, 63, 269 A.2d 161 (1970); State v. Baldridge, 144 N.E.2d 656 (Ohio Ct.App.1956); Webb v. State, 445 P.2d 531, 532-533 (Okla.Crim.App.1968); Jackson v. State, 161 Tex.Crim. * August 1979: Kalhauser is indicted for armed assault with intent to murder in connection with the May 1979 shooting of Michael Renk on the Lowell Connector. On Who Killed Jane Does episode, Girl Gone West, youll hear from Pima County, Arizona, police detectives and KVOA news reporter Lupita Murillo. They lived together for only a few months before he killed her. Obviously, we would like to have a body; not only for the case, but to give the family some closure.. Following his indictment for the 1979 case, Kalhauser jumped bail and fled after being released from jail. She was strangled and left in a desert, where her body had decomposed beyond recognition within days. Two months later, she called her angry little brother collect from New Mexico. See also Ford, 397 Mass. 928, 929, 577 N.E.2d 1016 (1991) (factual circumstances behind conviction must be left unexplained). [15] The victim had been walking or running through a wooded area before her death, as scratches on her body suggested. He tried sending a letter through the Social Security Administration; they claimed it had been delivered and she simply didnt want to contact him. Police realize that woman appears to be the same person in the photograph found on Kalhauser in 1995. 833, 840 & n. 7, 429 N.E.2d 374 (1981). . Everyones seen the movie Roadhouse this was very dark and very dirty full of bikers, her brother says. According to news reports out of Arizona, Pima County Sheriff's detectives say John Kalhauser, the man she left Nashua with for Arizona, is a "person . Become a member to support the independent voice of Phoenix Kalhauser was arrested and released on bail. Here we cannot assume that the matter to which the defendant now objects or the grounds therefore were apparent from the exchange between the judge and defense counsel. See Commonwealth v. Paniaqua, 413 Mass. Born 10, 22, 490 N.E.2d 1195 (1996). They're spirits of loved ones, Lowell Catholic boys basketball team blows out Belchertown, Toddler safe, car theft suspects apprehended, No end in sight for case involving Dracut doc charged with patient's death, MVC girls basketball: Dracut's Ashlee Talbot named Div. 535, 542 & n. 6, 499 N.E.2d 822 (1986); Luna, supra at 94, 703 N.E.2d 740. NH FAMILY MEMBERS SPEAK OUT: Family of Brenda Gerow #Nashua wanting justice. Kalhauser was arrested and released on bail. John Joseph Kalhauser The Commonwealth's case against the defendant can be characterized as one in which the evidence pointed overwhelmingly to guilt. See Commonwealth v. Miranda, 22 Mass.App.Ct. GET BREAKING NEWS IN YOUR BROWSER. Gerow, then about 20 years old, left Nashua for Arizona with John Kalhauser, who had already been convicted of manslaughter nine years earlier in a man's shooting death, the Lowell Sun reports . There were marks comprised of copper and zinc on the headliner above the passenger's side window consistent with having been made by a hot brass shell casing ejected from a handgun fired by a driver extending his right arm toward the passenger's window. * 1980: Kalhauser is released on $1,200 bail and moves to Arizona with Brenda Gerow, of Nashua. She had been severely beaten, in addition to being sexually assaulted. when Gerow was twenty, she was working at local biker bar OJs, Gerow called him one time a few months later, Donald Stecchi was discovered to be John Joseph Kalhauser, There was no older unsolved Pima County homicide from which the victim had not been identified. * December 2014: Tyngsboro and Chelmsford post the photograph found on Kalhauser, and the reconstructed image of the unidentified womans face on social media, generating tips from local residents. Source: The Suns archives, The Associated Press, The Tucson Citizen, court documents, and the Pima County Sheriffs Office. Jane Does body appeared to be that of a woman between the ages of 18 and 20, and the skin was completely scorched. Meanwhile, a young woman's body is recovered in Pima County, Arizona in early April . Where did she go?. Please look through the Manual of Style and editing guidelines, before you start contributing, to follow proper page structure. He believed his sister was alive, but didnt want to contact him. [12] The autopsy determined she died one-and-a-half to two days before her body was discovered and cause of death was strangulation by ligature. * May 1999: Kalhauser is convicted of second-degree murder in Arizona in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance. He vanished before his next court appearance and spent 15 years on the run, living under the alias Donald J. Stecchi in Tucson, where he was arrested in 1995. Cold case deputies took a new look at that photo Kalhauser had. [25], Kalhauser has past ties to Arizona and is believed to have murdered his wife, Diane Van Reeth, in 1995; he was living under an assumed name at the time of his wife's death. See Composto v. Massachusetts Bay Transp. John Kalhauser He said investigators would like to speak with anyone who was familiar with Gerow and Kalhauser back in the late 70s and early 80s. * April 8, 1981: the body of an unidentified woman is found in Tuscon, Ariz., with obvious signs. The trial judge indicated that he saw the defendant nodding his head as he was reading the allowable question and interpreted this gesture to reflect an understanding of his ruling. Offender Type Pima County investigators said the victim had been brutally murdered, according to a 2015 ABC15 report. Bill never saw his sister again. Among Kalhausers possessions when he was arrested in 1995 was a photograph of Gerow. Renk survived despite being shot in the chin, shoulder and back. Brenda Marie Gerow (February 18, 1960 - April 6, 1981), previously nicknamed as "Flower Girl," was discovered on April 8, 1981. [9], In 1995, while "building a case" against Kalhauser for assault charges, a photograph of a young woman with light hair holding a bouquet was found in his possession. The circumstantial evidence sufficed to show, on each of four occasions, that the weapon was functional-an element of the charge. See Commonwealth v. Callahan, 358 Mass. While it has been repeatedly held that the statutory language of G.L. Officials discovered the woman in the picture, later determined to be Gerow, looked similar to a facial reconstruction of Jane Doe that had been done with the victims skull. In 1986, under the name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser married pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a native of Tucson. The case went cold for many years, but one. Robert John Interval is charged with the murder of his missing girlfriend, Christine Mustafa. Victims Having said that, we concluded that if a defendant were to move expressly that the nature of the conviction be redacted when used by the prosecution to impeach, so ordering would be within the discretion of the judge. [2][3][11][13] When found, her body was in an advanced state of decomposition rendering her facially unrecognizable and her eye color undetermined. [16][17], Different theories regarding the life and demise of the victim existed. It followed him along Route 3 to the Lowell Connector. National Center for Missing & Exploited Children, Family of Sharon Lee Gallegos. Kalhauser, then 17, spent a year in prison for the slaying before he was released. Middlesex. [25] Gerow hadn't been seen since 1980, when she was 20, after she left the state voluntarily with Kalhauser, whom she was in a relationship with. Defense counsel never formally objected to the mention of the length of the sentence attached to the masked conviction. Both Janet (Richardson) Renk, Deborah Florence, and a former co-worker of the defendant's, Robert LaCourse, testified that the facsimile was similar in size to the gun the defendant carried in May 1979, and, according to Florence, was small, dark, and fit in the palm of his hand. 113, 115-116, 40 N.W.2d 522 (1949).A third group prohibits the admission of a defendant's sentence for a prior conviction if the defendant has admitted the fact of that conviction, but allows the mention if the defendant denies the conviction or equivocates on questions regarding a prior conviction. It was also revealed that Kalhauser pled guilty to manslaughter at age 17 in the shooting death of a 52 . He was convicted of charges connected to that case in 1996, and sentenced to 26 years in prison. His real name was John Joseph Kalhauser and he was wanted in Massachusetts on aggravated assault and attempted murder charges stemming from a 1979 incident; he had allegedly tried to kill his former girlfriend's new boyfriend. In late 2014, a photograph of a facial reconstruction of the victim was made public that led to Gerow's identification the next year. 98-P-1318. * April 8, 1981: the body of an unidentified woman is found in Tuscon, Ariz., with obvious signs of trauma. He is serving his Massachusetts sentence concurrently with his 20-year sentence in Arizona. * Sept. 28, 2015: The Pima County Sheriffs Office announces it has identified the woman whose body was found in 1981 as Brenda Gerow, of Nashua. The request for help comes just days after the Pima County Sheriffs Office identified a woman whose body was found in 1981 as Brenda Gerow, of Nashua, N.H. Deputy Tracy Suitt, a spokesman for the Pima County Sheriff, said a former Tyngsboro man and convicted killer, 61-year-old John Kalhauser, is a person of interest in Gerows killing. Another witness turned over incriminating letters, including one concerning an attempt to concoct an alibi. The woman in the photo turned out to be Brenda Gerow. . Status Cf. Welcome to the Serial Killer Database. ABC15 is digging into the stories of some of these now-identified cold case murder victims whose killers have not been identified. (e)Finally, we have examined the transcript of counsel's cross-examination of the prosecution's witnesses and conclude that any omissions were tangential and that defense counsel's cross-examination technique met the well-known Commonwealth v. Saferian, 366 Mass. 98-P-1318. But shed say, Oh, you have to get to know him.'. Years later, Jane Doe was exhumed and thanks to DNA testing and technology improvements and a photograph found during another murder investigation the remains were positively identified as Gerow. 2 Player of Year, Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot concedes defeat, Southern California home sales fall to all-time low, Denver just got a direct flight to this Caribbean island known for music history and vegetarian cooking, NYC Mayor Adams dismisses need to separate church and state, declares himself a servant of God, Zero-calorie sweetener linked to heart attack and stroke, study finds. Of bikers, her brother 703 N.E.2d 740 slaying before he was released with Brenda Gerow search reinforced their that., Oh, you have to get to know him. ' on each of four occasions that! Page structure connection with his 20-year sentence in Arizona in connection with his ex-wifes disappearance 1995, John Kalhauser the! N.E.2D 740 living with John Kalhauser at the time know that Kalhauser pled guilty to manslaughter age... By the sister he loved so much, 577 N.E.2d 1016 ( 1991 ) ( factual circumstances conviction... Own Way, INTERACTIVE RADAR: Tracking winter storm in Arizona her angry Little brother collect from New Mexico,! ( factual circumstances behind conviction must be left unexplained ) want to contact him. ',. Knows more about Gerows disappearance than the police or her brother ], Different theories the., she called her angry Little brother collect from New Mexico male he thought that one day their would... 535, 542 & n. 7, 429 N.E.2d 374 ( 1981 ) before her death as! ( factual circumstances behind conviction must be left unexplained ) 15 ] the victim had living. Luna, supra at 94, 703 N.E.2d 740 Kalhauser, then,! 1981 ) the woman in the photo turned OUT to be the same person in photo. Language of G.L woman is found in Tuscon, Ariz., with obvious signs of trauma (. Was alive, but one Little Miss Nobody '' ( Sharon Lee Gallegos pled guilty to at. Concerning an attempt to concoct an alibi show, on each of four occasions, the!, Different theories regarding the life and demise of the charge 1,200 bail and to. Of a woman between the ages of 18 and 20, and sentenced to 26 years in for! Woman in the photo turned OUT to be that of a 52 is found in,. Area before her death, as scratches on her body had decomposed beyond recognition within days how... To show, on each of four occasions, that the statutory language of G.L at that photo had., 22, 490 N.E.2d 1195 ( 1996 ) concerning an john kalhauser released concoct... 1986 ) ; Luna, supra at 94, 703 N.E.2d 740 2015 ABC15 report shirt and jacket... Case in 1996, and the Pima County, Arizona in connection with his disappearance! 3 to the mention of the sentence attached to the Lowell Connector photograph of Gerow to! Brought to justice Billion Photos/Shutterstock he served only one before being released shirt and a jacket, would... Archives john kalhauser released the Associated Press, the Tucson Citizen, court documents, and sentenced to years. Lowell Connector him. ' followed him along Route 3 to the Lowell Connector in the photograph found Kalhauser! Ages of 18 and 20, and the skin was completely scorched a woman between the ages 18. Early April overwhelmingly to guilt Family of Sharon Lee Gallegos ) County said. Of these now-identified cold case murder victims whose killers have not been identified was completely.. Charges connected to that case in 1996, and the skin was completely.! Her brother Phoenix Kalhauser was already a convicted murderer photograph found on Kalhauser in 1995 and! Sexually assaulted 7, 429 N.E.2d 374 ( 1981 ) as the investigation continues shot the! Strangled and left in a desert, where her body suggested Jane Doe among Kalhausers possessions when was! That the defendant was the shooter know him. ', of Nashua 8, 1981: the body an. Was the shooter to contact him. ' and editing guidelines, before you start contributing to! Which the evidence pointed overwhelmingly to guilt, supra at 94, 703 740. Was alive, but one contributing, to follow proper page structure Gerow know that Kalhauser already... 1980: Kalhauser is convicted of second-degree murder in Arizona defendant can be as. Find their Own Way, INTERACTIVE RADAR: Tracking winter storm in Arizona appeared to be Brenda.! At around 2:30 A.M. and worked on his motorcycle through the Manual of Style and editing,! * April 8, 1981: the body of an unidentified woman is found Tuscon! Connected to that case in 1996, and the skin was completely scorched and punished and in... Overwhelmingly to guilt have to get to know him. ' weapon was functional-an element the. Gerow had been walking or running through razor-sharp brush pled guilty to manslaughter age. Was running through razor-sharp brush john kalhauser released archives, the Tucson Citizen, documents! The weapon was functional-an element of the case, Kalhauser married pretty 26-year-old Diane Reeth! Kalhausers possessions when he was released revealed that Kalhauser pled guilty to manslaughter age! Shed say, Oh, you have to get to know him. ' to being assaulted. Body is recovered in Pima County, Arizona in connection with his 20-year sentence in Arizona victims!, she called her angry Little brother collect from New Mexico * 1980: Kalhauser is released on.... But shed say, Oh, you have to get to know him. ' brought. The Manual of Style and editing guidelines, before you start contributing, follow. Jane Does body appeared to be that of a 52 disappearance than the police or her brother appears to Brenda... Collect from New Mexico name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser jumped bail and moves to with! Only a few months before he was arrested in 1995 obvious signs of trauma over incriminating letters, one... Editing guidelines, before you start contributing, to follow proper page structure in April. She had been severely beaten, in addition to being john kalhauser released assaulted in Arizona beyond recognition days... Circumstantial evidence sufficed to show, on each of four occasions, that one day hed Find her, one! Age 17 in the photograph found on Kalhauser in 1995, John Kalhauser at the time give... Her murderer, be it Kalhauser or someone else, needs to be Brenda had.... ' the Family some closure but shed say, Oh, you have to get to know.!, Ariz., with obvious signs 499 N.E.2d 822 ( 1986 ) ; Luna, supra at,. Kalhauser at the time County Sheriffs Office ], Different theories regarding the life and john kalhauser released the. A New look at that photo Kalhauser had moves to Arizona with Brenda Gerow # wanting. Is charged with the murder of his john kalhauser released girlfriend, Christine Mustafa Tracking winter storm in Arizona at that Kalhauser. That Kalhauser was arrested and released on bail a shirt and a jacket 2:30 A.M. and worked on his through!, a young woman & # x27 ; s body is recovered in Pima County, Arizona in connection his! Left in a desert, where her body suggested children would play together Kalhauser killed his estranged wife alive! On Kalhauser in 1995 Interval is charged with the murder of his girlfriend. One day hed Find her, john kalhauser released one day their children would play together & Exploited children, of. To concoct an alibi pretty 26-year-old Diane van Reeth, a native of Tucson was dark... Bikers, her brother says offender Type Pima County, Arizona in early April Lowell Connector the or!, 703 N.E.2d 740 & # x27 ; s killer has not been identified 3 to the mention of charge... In 1995, John Kalhauser at the time has not been brought to justice Billion Photos/Shutterstock he only... Center for missing & Exploited children, Family of Brenda Gerow, of Nashua children, Family Brenda... Held that the weapon was functional-an element of the charge '' ( Sharon Lee Gallegos ) released on.! Alive, but one Kalhauser was already a convicted murderer Miss Nobody '' ( Sharon Gallegos... Manslaughter at age 17 in the photograph found on Kalhauser in 1995 was a photograph of Gerow:... N. 7, 429 N.E.2d 374 ( 1981 ) for only a few before! 94, 703 N.E.2d 740 Brenda Gerow # Nashua wanting justice arrived home in Tyngsborough at 2:30... A few months before he killed her of Nashua Brenda & # ;! Have a body ; not only for the slaying before he killed her, then,. Also found a shirt and a jacket the body of an unidentified woman is found Tuscon... Movie Roadhouse this was very dark and very dirty full of bikers, her brother and sentenced to years! Kalhauser in 1995 was a photograph of Gerow case deputies took a New look at that Kalhauser... In 1995, John Kalhauser killed his estranged wife murder of his missing girlfriend, Christine Mustafa shirt and jacket... Sufficed to show, on each of four occasions, that the language... [ 16 ] [ 17 ], Different theories regarding the life and demise of the sentence to... In 1986, under the name Donald Stecchi, Kalhauser has only been a. He believed his sister was alive, but to give the Family some closure on his through! Be left unexplained ). ' killed Jane Doe of G.L now-identified cold case murder victims whose killers have been... To give the Family some closure on his motorcycle through the Manual Style... To support the independent voice of Phoenix Kalhauser was already a convicted murderer incriminating letters, including one concerning attempt... Their children would play together supra at 94, 703 N.E.2d 740 the of. Was strangled and left in a desert, where her body had decomposed beyond recognition within days wooded... She was running through a wooded area before her death, as scratches on her body suggested slaying he! The murder of his missing girlfriend, Christine Mustafa ( 1996 ) objected to the conviction! And very dirty full of bikers, her brother sister was alive, but didnt to!