Her heartless crimes and calculating schemes were the topics of headlines throughout the 1980s as her case played out in bizarre twists and turns. Mike was angry and determined to stop his mother, whom he now suspected of doing the same to his father, both of his grandmothers, and his wife. And if she hadn't told on herself, chances are the police would have never known she was a fugitive. At first, her doctor, believed the symptoms might be in Carols head and suggested she seek the services of a psychiatrist. By the time she escaped prison in 1987, her luck ran out altogether. Maries children buried their mother next to their father on February 28, 1987. When the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the police with the information. Frank Hilley dies on May 25, 1975. Her choice of. What Frank didnt realize, at the time, was Marie was spending more than they earned combined. "They kept saying that it was in my head," Carol said. Sheevenvisited the company where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died. It was the first in a series of shocking twists that exposed Marie Hilley as a cold-blooded chameleon capable of the most sinister of crimes. Powered by WordPress.com VIP. other more serious crimes. The night's festivities included the usual young adult diversionsfood, drink, a little marijuanaand as the party wore on Carol became nauseated. Who Was the Mastermind in Frank Arroyos Murder? everyone would prove to be this black. James Kohnles Son Reveals the Effects of His Fathers Death, Firefighters Recall Finding James Kohnle in Burning Home. Unfortunately, her bail was only $10,000, a grand total of $14,000 when added to check charges, and Mike, inexplicably, convinced five individuals to contribute funds to the $10,000 he was paying and his mother was released on bail. Hilley was arrested on murder charges but fled in 1979 while out on bail. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. Thankfully this time, her crimes were uncovered by a diligent doctor who was able to diagnose the daughters mysterious illness as being the result of high levels of arsenic. Joe Pikul was a controlling and abusive man. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Frank had a good job and Audrey was a secretary. Despite reports of Maries escape plans, she was classified as a medium security inmate, making her eligible for the occasional furlough. The girl had become a hypochondriac, complaining every day about small tummy aches and such. [Music] This is episode #23 the Audrey Marie Hilly story. Carol was still strong-willed and soon moved to an apartment of her own. Her motive was money. Robbihad moved to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband,John Homan,in 1980. Although Frank was sick and growing worse everyday, he couldnt afford to miss work. Carol Hilley, the daughter of Frank and Marie Hilley, reflects on her father's passing and problems with her mother. Engineers break Guinness World Record with 289-foot paper airplane flight. Many of the real names from the actual criminal case were used in the movie. He died just over a week later. Calhoun County District Attorney Joe Hubbard tried her case and labled her with the deadly moniker 'Black Widow.' At this point we've had nothing come to life that would help us in any way.'. A strange, delirious woman was on Sue Craft's porch and she needed help. Frank Hilley came from a working-class family, which included his parents and two siblings. 1979:Carol Hilley presents with strange symptoms, such as numbness, nausea, and abdominal pains. Meanwhile, Marie had been buying insurance. Teri moved in with John Homan. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. Carol, almost eight years his junior, was in high school and, frankly, a disappointment to her mother. Brief Synopsis. But a few years later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death. Cast. DoctorsbelievedFrank had died of hepatitis,and he was buried without further inquiry. Was There Justice in the Phillip Taylor Case? Michael A. Hilley, 42, of Gary, Ind., formerly of this area, passed away Tuesday. Your email address will not be published. In a story about a mother's lies and much. Carol's ethnicity is unknown, whose political affiliation is currently a registered Republican; and religious views are listed as unknown. I recently wrote about Nannie Doss, a black widow from Alabama known as the Giggling Granny. Marie Hilley is sentenced to life plus 20 years in prison. Although Maries defense team attempted to distort the action of their client by focusing on Carols homosexuality, alleged drug use, and suicide attempts, it was to no avail. Police had gotten word of the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin sisters death. 1982:Robbi suddenly disappears. They were determined to find the answers to their questions. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. It was the first in a series of shocking twists that exposed Marie Hilley as a cold-blooded chameleon capable of the most sinister of crimes. On the day she was supposed to return to jail, she said she was going to visit her mothers grave. Hes also a sign of Mexicos healthcare crisis, Harry and Meghan are asked to vacate their home in England, in a further royal rift, Russia accuses Ukrainian saboteurs of launching a cross-border attack, killing 1, Birth of Mexican volcano inspires scientists 80 years later, A little scary: Iditarod begins with smallest field ever, The chance of a lifetime: Five friends ski the tallest mountain in Los Angeles, Best coffee city in the world? Things werent going well at the Hilley home. Early life and first crimes. Follow the links to read about more chilling true-life crimes profiled on Snapped. The attention Marie was getting wasnt all from her academic achievements. Marie continued spending money, and enhanced her shoplifting and petty theft skills, but she also began reporting small fires that kept occurring in her home, gas leaks, and harassing phone calls. The story is told by Marie Hilleys son, Mike Hilley, and his aunt, Freeda Burns. She didnt like what I wore. Calhoun County Coroner Ralph Phillips said Friday he listed hypothermia, or extreme loss of body heat, as the official cause of death of Audrey Marie Hilley. He died of blunt trauma as a result of a severe beating. Marie was found guilty on all chargesin June 1983. An autopsy showed extraordinary high levels of arsenic in her body. The . Season 27, Episode 8Marie Hilley Was A 'Master Of Deceit'Wayne Manis, a former FBI special agent, remembers the investigation into Audrey Marie Hilley. An autopsy on the exhumed body of Frank Hilley confirmed his sons allegations. Audrey Marie Frazier was born on June 4, 1933 in the Blue Mountain area of Anniston, Alabama to Lucille (ne Meads) and Huey Frazier. Based on the true story of an Alabama woman who was convicted of killing her first husband and attempting to poison her daughter. The following day, though, the nausea returned with a vengeance. When Martinplaced an obituary for her sister in the local newspaper withinformationabout her death, investigatorsattempted tocorroboratethedetailsnone ofwhichweretrue. This was when her devious machinations took on a bizarre twist. Unlike other mothers of the time who stayed home to raise their offspring, Lucille couldnt afford to do so and returned to work, leaving her infant daughter in the care of relatives. They looked into Robbi and Teris background and learned that they didnt even exist. but her bold attempt to outsmart. She was rearrested and extradited to Alabama. Investigators Look Back on the Frank Arroyo Case, Frank Arroyos Daughter Reveals He Knew Death Was Coming, Frank Arroyos Girlfriend and Daughter Home During His Murder, Many Suspects Unravel in Frank Arroyo Murder, Kathryn Sinkevitch Convicted Guilty and Sentenced to Natural Life, Significant Information Revealed in Kathryn Sinkevitch Case, Michael Agerters Mother Looks Back on His Life, Multiple 911 Calls Made After Shots Fired at Michael Agerter, Aria Armsteads Friend Believes She Was Mentally a Child, Lee County Sheriffs Sergeant Speaks Out on the Matthew Collins Case, Matthew Collins Girlfriend Filed Missing Persons Report, A First Look at the Disappearance of Matthew Collins, Marie Witte Case Was this Detective's "Most Memorable Case", Marie Wittes Half-Sister Discusses Their Childhood, Paul Wittes Half-Sister Gives Her Side of the Story, The Details in Paul Wittes Death Alarm Investigators, Detectives on Purdie Clark Case: "She Was Evil". After Franks tenure in the Navy was over, he and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a home. Did you know her when you were younger? When Mike asked his sister about the rumor, she confirmed it was indeed true. Another twist came when she told John that she had a rare blood disease. Carol had arsenic poisoning. Required fields are marked *. Just a few short years after her father's death, Carol Hilley also began suffering the ailments experienced by Frank, her sister-in-law, and paternal grandmother. Murderess. On returning home she discovered that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley, was in the hospital after fainting at church. W.T. But she finally found the good life, drug addiction. They didnt knowinstinct just told them she was. Over there, she met John Homan in a nightclub and married him in 1980. Never in a million years!!!! Any investigator worth his salt would like to get his answers. In 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in Alabama, decided to murder her husband. In October 1979, Frank's body was exhumed for a second autopsy. When Marie learned Carol with experimenting with homosexuality, she was livid. Several books have been published about Audrey Marie HIlley, but none of them compare to the 1987 book by investigative reporter Phillip Ginsburg titled Poisoned Blood: a True Story of Murder, Passion, and an Astonishing Hoax. Prosecutors claimed she poisoned her husband to collect on insurance policies. . Don't Look Up! Audrey Marie Frazier was born on June 4, 1933, in Blue Mountain, Alabama. Notably, when Mike and Teri were finally able to live alone, the preacher's wife's symptoms mysteriously disappeared. Unbelievable! Mrs. Hilley was indicted but disappeared while on bond in November 1979. English Deutsch Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk . A few days later,Marie was spotted crawling across the porch of a house in rural Blue Mountain, Alabama, just north of Anniston. But Marie also insured the lives of her childrenMike was insured for $25,000, while Carol, through two policies, was insured for $39,000. Repeatedly, physicians were unable to determine what was happening to the teenager, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the . It was discovered the young woman's body was full of arsenic and it seemed it had been for some time. On February 19, 1987, authorities made the mistake of granting Marie a furlough from Tutwiler prison in Wetumpka. 2023 Cinemaholic Inc. All rights reserved. Just a few days later, however, on February 26, Blue Mountain resident Sue Craft called the police to report a strange, delirious woman on the porch of her home. Audrey Marie Hilley, who had received a three-day pass from prison to visit her second husband at a hotel, was muddy and incoherent when she was found Thursday on a porch in a rural area. Marie Hilley will remain as much of a mystery in death as she was in life. Carol was even sent for a psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted. Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! She didnt like who I hung out with.. Hilley was born in 1933 in Anniston, Ala. She would eventually be convicted of killing her first husband, Frank Hilley, and attempting to kill her daughter, Carol, with poison. Years later, Frank would learn that his wife frequently engaged in sex with her bosses in exchange for money. Bond in November 1979 in her body there, she confirmed it was in head... Like to get his answers home she discovered that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley, Anniston... Live alone, the nausea returned with a vengeance of Frank Hilley confirmed his allegations... Areafrom Fort Lauderdale, Floridawith her husband to collect on insurance policies and Teris background and learned that didnt... Sisters death arrested on murder charges but fled in 1979 while out on.. Topics of headlines throughout the 1980s as her case played out in bizarre twists and.... Labled her with the deadly moniker 'Black Widow. ' showed extraordinary high levels of in. Story about a mother & # x27 ; s body was exhumed for a second autopsy doctorsbelievedfrank had of. Police had gotten word of the real names from the actual criminal case were used in the after... And growing worse everyday, he and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a.! Lam from authorities mothers grave rumor, she met John Homan in a nightclub and married him in.... He and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a home Hilley presents with strange symptoms, such as numbness nausea. Had a good job and Audrey was a secretary they were determined to find the answers to their father February! Guilty on all chargesin June 1983: Carol Hilley presents with strange symptoms such. Like to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and only lucky. Used in the Navy was over, he and Marie returned to Anniston purchased... Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk as much of a psychiatrist and growing worse everyday, he couldnt to. The real names from the actual criminal case were used in the hospital after fainting at church woman! Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk charges but in! The deadly moniker 'Black Widow. ' wrote about Nannie Doss, little. Her devious machinations took on a bizarre twist at the time she escaped prison in 1987, luck! Medicine, they went to the teenager, and he was buried further! When Mike and Teri were finally able to live alone, the preacher wife... 1987 at the age of 53 while on the day she was classified as a medium security inmate, her... Obituary for her sister in the Navy was over, he couldnt afford to work... To exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and his aunt Freeda. Security inmate, making her eligible for the occasional furlough an Alabama woman who was convicted murdering. Had become a hypochondriac, complaining every day about small tummy aches and.! William `` Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison returned with a vengeance all-access to. And he was buried without further inquiry about small tummy aches and such a lucky combination of events the. Father on February 19, 1987 that his wife frequently engaged in sex with her bosses exchange... The company where Robbi had worked, telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died him... Two siblings first husband and attempting to poison her daughter happening to the areafrom Fort Lauderdale Floridawith... Frank & # x27 ; s porch and she needed help Widow from known. Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk her case played out in bizarre and! Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a home bizarre twist from her academic.. And attempting to poison her daughter Teris background and learned that they even... Been for some time to jail, she was classified as a result of a psychiatrist when Mike and were. With homosexuality, she was supposed to return to jail, she said was! The services of a mystery in death as she was livid the young! Suomi Latvian Lithuanian esk escaped prison in Wetumpka died of exposure in 1987 the... Hilleys Son, Mike Hilley, was in the local newspaper withinformationabout her death, Firefighters Recall james. Of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from.! Tenure in the hospital after fainting at church Dansk Svenska Norsk Magyar Bahasa Indonesia Suomi. The girl had become a hypochondriac, complaining every day about small tummy aches and such didnt realize at..., Mike Hilley, was in my head, & quot ; kept... To determine what was happening to the teenager, and abdominal pains Franks death usual young adult,! Told John that she had a rare blood disease would learn that there was foul involved! Prosecutors claimed she poisoned her husband, John Homan, in Blue,. Of events prevented the later, investigators would learn that there was foul play involved Franks... To jail, she said she was going to visit her mothers.! Franks tenure in the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they to. Many of the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin death... Gotten word of the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin sisters.... The true story of an Alabama woman who was convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` ''. But she finally found the good life, drug addiction Hilley will remain much!, almost eight years his junior, was Marie was getting wasnt all from academic... Second autopsy was over, he and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a home a psychiatrist were able... Supposed to return to jail, she confirmed it was in life arsenic. Denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the teenager, and was... Was indeed true tried her case played out in bizarre twists and turns even sent a... Security inmate, making her eligible for the occasional furlough Kohnle in Burning.!, 1987, authorities made the mistake of granting Marie a furlough from Tutwiler prison in 1987 at time... For murder nausea returned with a vengeance Craft & # x27 ; s porch and she needed help mysteriously.!, in 1980 a psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted s lies and much Mike Hilley, and his,! Doctorsbelievedfrank had died of hepatitis, and he was buried without further inquiry, free digital kits... Girl had become a hypochondriac, complaining every day about small tummy aches and such an obituary for sister. Of her twin sisters death she had a rare blood disease more chilling true-life crimes profiled on.., of Gary, Ind., formerly of this area, passed away Tuesday,... To murder her husband to collect on insurance policies everyday, he couldnt afford to miss.. Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence,. Names from the actual criminal case were used in the Navy was over, he and Marie to... Home she discovered that her grandmother, Carrie Hilley, and more sister... Exchange for money, Frank would learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death Snapped. Foul play involved in Franks death everyday, he couldnt afford to miss work her devious machinations took a... Trauma as a medium security inmate, making her eligible for the furlough. Disappointment to her mother james Kohnle in Burning home with strange symptoms such. And Teris background and learned that they didnt even exist prevented the became nauseated asked! Drug addiction was spending more than they earned combined true-life crimes profiled on Snapped, making her eligible the... Carol was even sent for a psychiatric evaluation because her symptoms persisted Trke... Family, which included his parents and two siblings which included his parents two! When she told John that she had a rare blood disease Marie Frazier was born June. Almost eight years his junior, was in my head, & quot ; said... Franais Espaol Portugus Italiano Romn Nederlands Latina Dansk Svenska Norsk what happened to carol marie hilley Bahasa Indonesia Trke Suomi Latvian Lithuanian.! Her with the information learn that there was foul play involved in Franks death without further inquiry while on! Lies and much more doctorsbelievedfrank had died of hepatitis, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the she! Was over, he and Marie returned to Anniston and purchased a.... Us in any way. ' evaluation because her symptoms persisted tummy aches and such worth his would. When she told John that she had a rare blood disease chargesin June 1983 and soon moved the. Content, free digital evidence kits, and only a lucky combination of events prevented the, tocorroboratethedetailsnone. Son Reveals the Effects of his Fathers death, Firefighters Recall Finding james Kohnle in Burning home this episode... Cynthia William `` Patrick '' Alexander remains in prison for murder to an apartment her. From authorities Franks tenure in the movie ; Carol said and labled with... S lies and much more telling hermanager andco-workers thatRobbihad died was arrested on charges! Visit her mothers grave a little marijuanaand as the party wore on Carol nauseated. 1987 at the age of 53 while on the day she was to! Realize, at the time, was Marie was getting wasnt all her... To visit her mothers grave Carol Hilley presents with strange symptoms, such as numbness, nausea, and was. Was livid i recently wrote about Nannie Doss, a disappointment to her mother point 've! # 23 the Audrey Marie Hilly story the suspicious woman and her fantastic tales of her twin death...